Buy!
This replaces my prior top recommendation for a daily face sunscreen (Keys - Solar Rx Broad Spectrum Sunblock). It's a fantastic Zinc Oxide based sunscreen that I found to be entirely non-greasy and non-whitening. I frequently wear it both alone and with makeup and my face looks smooth and non-shiny, and it has a wonderful light citrus scent. The only downside that I can see is that there is a lot of packaging and it isn't recyclable.
The sunscreen has an environmental working group score of 1, with excellent UVA protection and good UVB protection.
Buy it on amazon (for $45 - eek).
